As a huge fan of the graphic novel I was really excited to
see this back when it hit cinema screens.
The look of the film was
stunning and I think Zack Snyder got the balance right on what to put
into the story and what to leave out this cinematic version and save for
the extended DVD.
Rorschach and Nite Owl II were just how I imagined them to be in the flesh. I think Jackie Earle Haley really nailed Rorschach and Patrick Wilson as Nite Owl II was very good.
It
was a nice touch to have Nite Owl there when Rorschach died as it made
for a more emotional scene compared to the book where he died alone with
nobody there but Dr.Manhattan.Rorschach and Nite Owl II were just how I imagined them to be in the flesh. I think Jackie Earle Haley really nailed Rorschach and Patrick Wilson as Nite Owl II was very good.
On the subject of Doctor Manhattan I
might as well get out the way what everyone was talking about and that
would be his very blue penis. I never really noticed it after the first
time to be honest but I am glad they decided to keep him how he is for
the film and not give him some permanent underwear as that wasn't what
he was all about.
Maybe there would of been more of an uproar if it had been one of the human characters with their schlong forever hanging out?
As
for the 'sex' scene on Archie (The ship) between Nite Owl II and Silk
Spectre I would admit that seemed a bit out of place with the content
and maybe should be cut down for the DVD. It was like watching poor porn
(Or so I have heard) and it did make me chuckle for all the wrong
reasons. I don't think what that was all about was really covered on
film like it was in the book and so it came across completely different
to what it should of been.
I
was also chuffed that the scenes from the book I wanted to see were in
there. Don't read too much into my mental state about that please as
they were mostly violent scenes involving Rorschach in prison.
I loved the cooking fat mutilation and the whole time he spent in prison although it was short compared to (dare I say it again) the book and I don't think he should of got his costume back straight away.
I loved the cooking fat mutilation and the whole time he spent in prison although it was short compared to (dare I say it again) the book and I don't think he should of got his costume back straight away.
He was without it a while after he was freed in the book if I remember correctly.
I also did not see any problems with the look of President Nixon (some people have commented he looked fake) as I took it that he was just a caricature from the book and that was what was being aimed for.
The minor changes in the film really did not bother me at all and I
would go as far to say in some respects it made it better. I really did
not have a problem with the new ending either.I also did not see any problems with the look of President Nixon (some people have commented he looked fake) as I took it that he was just a caricature from the book and that was what was being aimed for.
I think Zack Snyder
has done a good job of bringing this film to the screen and he deserves
praise considering the development hell this project had been in for
well over twenty years. He has received a lot of stick from fans while
making this and I think he has did a fine job.
I would go as
far as saying Watchmen is the most faithful adaption of it's
genre ever and unfortunately that also may be it's downfall when it
comes to non-fans of the book. Do you need to read the novel to
appreciate this movie? I think it would help but then I know people that
have not read it and have really enjoyed it.
I love it though and I 100% recommend you check out the three hour director cut as well.
I love it though and I 100% recommend you check out the three hour director cut as well.